Joseph Elliott's Severe Sentence - Sheffield 1927

Pearl Street Sheffield just prior to demolition

The Sheffield Daily Independent dated Tuesday 15th February 1927 carried this report of a razor attack on 19 year old Martha Norman by her 21 year old boyfriend of 3 years, Joseph William Elliott. The attack was carried out on the evening of Sunday 16th January 1927 at 115 Pearl Street, the home of Martha's parents.

It is a clear case of attempted murder, Dr. Girling pointed  out that that Martha's life was in danger for days after the attack but had since recovered from a deep wound to the windpipe. 

The trial took place at the West Riding Assizes in Leeds on 4th April 1927. 

The Sheffield Daily Independent dated 05th April 1927 carried this report of the proceedings.

 They found Joseph Elliott NOT GUILTY of Attempted Murder but GUILTY of "Wounding with Intent to cause Grievous Bodily Harm." The Lord Chief Justice seems to have been taken aback by the Jury's verdict. The evidence strongly supports a verdict of attempted murder but the members of the jury for some unfathomable reason decided to ignore the evidence and return a verdict that was "lenient." Joseph Elliott was given a "somewhat severe" sentence of five years penal servitude as this was deemed to be in the public interest.  

In my view the key element in the verdict was Martha's downplaying the attack. In the committal in February she stated that she had come to the view that he did not mean to harm her and that it was just an ordinary lovers quarrel. A similar disposition was made at the Assizes and was instrumental in the Jury returning a verdict of wounding with intent as opposed to attempted murder. Joseph Elliott could be described as fortunate in not receiving a sentence that reflected the sheer horror of the assault on Martha.

It appears that Joseph served his sentence in Maidstone prison in Kent and was released early on 18th December 1930 after serving about three years of his sentence 

1921 Census

Prison Record for Joseph William Elliott - HMP Maidstone 

Just over two years later, Joseph married 22 year old Norah Brown at St Matthews Church 

1932 Marriage Record for Joseph Elliott

St Matthews Church Carver Street Sheffield  - Photograph taken 6th March 2008

1939 National Register - the couple were living at 240 East Bank Road. It appears that Joseph was no longer a plasterer but working in the steel mills of Sheffield

As far as I can ascertain Joseph Elliott died in Sheffield in January 1966 age 60. His wife Nora died 22 years later in 1982.  

Martha can be found in the 1911 and 1921 Census living with her family and siblings at 115 Pearl Street Sheffield.  

1911 Census

1921 Census

The attempt on Martha's life took place at 115 Pearl Street on 16th January 1927 but after spending a period in Sheffield's Royal Hospital recovering from a life threatening injury she returned home. But nearly three years later she left home and married Harry Leonard Piearcey on 22nd November 1930.  

Marriage Record 1930

A family tree on Ancestry then outlined the remainder of Martha's life

1907 Birth 29 Nov 1907 • Sheffield, Yorkshire, England
1910 Birth of sister Evelyn Norman (1910–1911) Sheffield, Yorkshire, England
1911 Residence 02 Apr 1911 • Ecclesall, Yorkshire-West Riding, England
1911 Death of sister Evelyn Norman (1910–1911) October 1911 • Ecclesall Bierlow, Yorkshire West Riding
1919 Birth of sister Eileen Norman (1919–2005) 24/03/1919 • Sheffield, Yorkshire, England
1923 Birth of sister Joyce Perchal (1923–1991) 6 Dec 1923 • Ecclesall Bierlow, Yorkshire West Riding
1930 Marriage Oct 1930 • Ecclesall Bierlow, Yorkshire West Riding, United Kingdom Harry L Piearcey 1905–1979
1939 Residence Yorkshire (West Riding), England
1945 Residence Rother Valley, West Yorkshire, England
1946 Death of father George William Norman (1880–1946) Dec 1946 • Sheffield, Yorkshire West Riding, England
1960 Death of sister Polly Norman (1905–1960) Sep 1960 • Sheffield, Yorkshire West Riding, England
1969 Death of mother Mary Warburton (1881–1969) 17 Sep 1969 • Sheffield, Yorkshire West Riding, England
1979 Death of husband Harry L Piearcey (1905–1979) Jul 1979 • Sheffield, South Yorkshire, England
1991 Death of sister Joyce Perchal (1923–1991) 14 March 1991 • Louth, Lincolnshire, England
1996 Death Aug 1996 • Sheffield, Yorkshire, England

Martha lived to be the grand age of 88!

 

Bridlington 1963

Sources

Sheffield Daily Independent dated Tuesday 15th February 1927

Sheffield Daily Independent dated 5th April 1927

The Scotsman dated 5th April 1927

Sheffield Indexers

Ancestry

Return To Main Homepage

This page was last updated on 04/11/26 10:28